----------------------------------------------------------
Transactions on Data Privacy           http://www.tdp.cat/
----------------------------------------------------------

Authors:
Title:
Paper-ID: 

ACCEPTANCE (scale 1-5):

[ ] Accept as written
[ ] Minor revision
[ ] Major revision (needs re-review)
[ ] Reject (unsuitable for publication)
[ ] Transfer to more suitable publication

GENERAL EVALUATION:
(1: excellent; 5: bad)

DETAILED EVALUATION
(1: completely agree/true; 5: disagree/false)

Is the topic relevant to TDP?
Does the paper make a valuable contribution?
Is the paper deep?

Is the presentation good (clarity and organization)?
Is the language acceptable?
Is the title appropriate?
Is the abstract appropriate?
Are the references appropriate?

TYPE OF PAPER:

[ ] Research paper
[ ] Application paper
[ ] Other (please specify):

- Technical soundness:
[ ] Technically correct (after careful check)
[ ] Apparently correct (after superficial check)
[ ] Minor errors (please indicate them)
[ ] Major errors (please indicate them)
[ ] Unsupported claims

- For applications and methods analysis:
[ ] Conclusive analysis
[ ] Real world problems
[ ] Toy problems
[ ] Application description (no experiments described)

Are the experiments explained with enough detail?

Can an interested reader reproduce the experiments?


REMARKS TO BE FORWARDED TO THE AUTHORS
(please indicate here what needs to be revised).






-----------------------------------------------------------------
COMMENTS FOR THE EDITORS IN CHIEF (not shown to the authors):

Reviewer:

What is your expertise concerning the subject area of this paper ?
[ ] I am an expert
[ ] I am knowleadgeable in the area, though not an expert
[ ] I only have a superficial knowledge